Goodwill-Oikerhe v. Commissioner: A Case Study in Substantiation Failures and Civil Fraud Penalties
The Tax Court’s recent memorandum opinion in Goodwill-Oikerhe v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-18, serves as a stark reminder of the rigorous substantiation standards required to support deductions and the severe consequences of failing to meet them. The case involves a petitioner who was not only a taxpayer but a "highly educated individual" with a master’s degree in accounting and a professional tax return preparer.
The Court sustained the IRS’s disallowance of numerous personal and business deductions and, notably, upheld the imposition of Section 6663 civil fraud penalties. For tax professionals, this opinion reinforces the critical importance of maintaining adequate records and the futility of "implausible or inconsistent explanations" when facing examination.
Read More