Disallowance of COVID-19 Leave Credits: A Review of Substantiation and Trade or Business Requirements
Marie M. Kanda v. Commissioner, T.C. Summary Opinion 2026-3 (Docket No. 3772-24S. Filed April 20, 2026)
Between 2015 and 2023, Marie M. Kanda suffered from several serious health conditions, including breast cancer and severe osteoarthritis, which led to her doctor determining she was disabled and unable to work. During these years, she collected Social Security disability payments and notably never contracted COVID-19. Despite her medical status, Kanda claimed that she worked part-time on weekends cleaning and vacuuming vehicles for two to three hours a day. She failed to maintain contemporaneous business records for this activity, relying instead on her husband to keep track of limited customer invoices and handwritten monthly expense reports that were never recorded in a formal ledger. Furthermore, while Kanda and her husband signed a written partnership agreement in November 2020 to operate "Kanda Auto Service," they never filed a partnership tax return for 2021.
Kanda's tax reporting history was highly inconsistent. On her 2020 joint return, Kanda and her husband reported zero self-employment income, showing only $21,100 in unemployment income. For the 2021 tax year—the year at issue—Kanda filed married filing separately, reported her occupation as "childcare," but attached a Schedule C for an "auto mechanic" business showing $19,865 in gross receipts and $10,190 in net business income. Alongside this, she claimed $28,000 in refundable COVID-19-related sick and family leave credits ($12,900 under the Families First Coronavirus Response Act (FFCRA) and $15,100 under the American Rescue Plan Act of 2021 (ARPA)). Kanda did not include Form 7202, Credits for Sick Leave and Family Leave for Certain Self-Employed Individuals, with her original return. When audited, she submitted the form claiming $80,650 in net earnings from self-employment, electing to use her prior year (2020) net earnings, an amount drastically contradicting her filed 2020 return. She also provided an unsigned alternative 2020 return listing $6,700 in self-employment income, demonstrating three entirely different positions taken regarding her 2020 self-employment income.
Read More