Procedures Released for Application for Waiver of Electronic Filing for Forms 5500-EZ and Form 8955-SSA

Sometimes there are hardships that may make it difficult for a taxpayer to file certain reports electronically even where such filing is required.  In Revenue Procedure 2015-47 the IRS has issued guidance on requesting such a hardship waiver for plan administrators that are required to file Forms 5500-EZ (Annual Return of One-Participant (Owners and Their Spouses) Retirement Plan) and/or Form 8955-SSA (Annual Registration Statement Identifying Separated Participants With Deferred Vested Benefits).

Read More

Lack of Regulations Does Not Allow IRS to Refuse to Consider Application for Extended Replacement Period Where Statute is Self-Executing

If the tax law provides for an application for special treatment to be made in such time and manner as the IRS may require, can a taxpayer make the application if the IRS hasn’t gotten around to writing any regulations or provided other guidance on the subject?  This was the issue addressed by Chief Counsel Memorandum 201537021.

Read More

Even Though Statute Expired Under §4979A, Failure to File Form 5330 Meant Statute Remained Open Under §6501 to Assess Excise Tax on ESOP

In ruling on a motion for reconsideration in the case of Law Office of John H. Eggertsen, P.C. v. Commissioner, 143 TC No. 13 the Tax Court addressed the interaction of provisions governing the statute of limitations for the excise tax on prohibited allocations of employer securities in an ESOP imposed by IRC §4979A.

Read More

Referral to Collection Agency By Itself Not Sufficent to Rebut 36 Month Presumption of Debt Cancellation

The timing of cancellation of debt and the simple reality that banks often issue 1099C’s in a year other than the one where the income event took place came back to haunt the IRS yet again in the case of Clark v. Commissioner, TC Memo 2015-175.  But it had the interesting twist of the Court determining that the mere referral of a debt to a collection agency by a bank did not, by itself, show there had been substantial efforts expended in various years to collect the debt.

Read More

Taxpayer Not Allowed to Use Open Transaction Doctrine to Avoid Reporting Interest Income, Penalties Applied

The open transaction doctrine, if applicable to a case (and that’s a really big if), provides that a taxpayer generally treats amounts received as a return of capital until the taxpayer’s basis has been entirely recovered.  Unfortunately for the taxpayers in the case of Friedman v. Commissioner, TC Memo 2015-177, the Tax Court did not find their situation to be one where that doctrine applied.

Read More

Clauses in Trust Did Not Render Crummey Withdraw Right Illusory, But Court Finds IRS Position Sufficiently Justified Not to Award Legal Fees

The IRS lost in its attempt to claim a taxpayer’s attempt at providing a Crummey power to trust beneficiaries failed to grant a present interest in the case of Mikel v. Commissioner, TC Memo 2015-64.  The IRS’s claim was that there were effectively restrictions imposed on the beneficiary’s withdrawal rights that meant they had no real present interest.

Under IRC §2503(b)(1) an annual exclusion (with an annual cap that is adjusted for inflation) is allowed for gifts to beneficiaries of a present interest in property.  Reg. §25.2503-3(b) provides that a present interest in property is “[a]n unrestricted right to the immediate use, possession, or enjoyment of property or the in- come from property.”

Read More

Snow Day in Washington DC Treated as Holiday for Purposes of Determining Due Date for Filing a Tax Court Petition

The Tax Court decided, at least for purposes of filing a petition with the Tax Court, that a federal “snow day” declared in the District of Columbia that falls on the last day for filing with the Court serves to push the due date back to the first day the office of the clerk of the Tax Court was open.  The issue was decided in an order filed in the case of Guralnik v. Commissioner, Docket No. 4358-15 L, Order dated August 24, 2015.

Read More

Origin of the Claim Test Used to Analyze Deductibility of Legal Expenses Incurred in Patent Infringement Litigation

Deductibility of legal expenses is always a tricky issue for tax purposes.  In the situation described in Private Letter Ruling 201536006 the litigation involved a potential infringement on a patent, with a key issue being whether the legal fees incurred represented a capitalizable payment in defense of title to the patent or an ordinary and necessary business expense arising from a dispute over whether there had been an infringement on the patent.

Read More

IRS Grants Late Portability Election Conditioned on Representation That No Form 706 Was Required

In Private Letter Ruling 201536005 the IRS granted an executrix, who was also the surviving spouse of the decedent,  the right to make a late portability election under IRC §2010.  By making that election, the estate of the surviving spouse will be able to take into account the decedent’s deceased spousal unused exclusion amount (DSUE).

Read More

Seventh Circuit Agrees There Is No Capital Gain Treatment for Reward Received under False Claims Act Since There Was No Sale or Exchange of a Capital Asset

Taxpayers were again beaten back in an attempt to broadly define a “capital asset” and a “sale of a capital asset” in order to gain access to the preferential capital gain tax rates in the case of Patrick v. Commissioner, 142 TC No. 5, affirmed on appeal by the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals, Case No. 14-2190.

In this case the taxpayers were looking to get capital gain treatment for an amount they received as a reward for, effectively, turning in the husband’s employer through a qui tam complaint filed under the False Claims Act.

Read More

IRS Concludes One Paragraph Was Inadequate Disclosure of Gift, Statute Remains Open Indefinitely

In Legal Advice Issued by Field Attorneys 20152201F the IRS conclude disclosures related to a gift were inadequate on the gift tax return that was filed by the taxpayer.  That is important because, under IRC §6501(c)(9) if there is inadequate disclosure of a gift on a gift tax return the statute of limitations stays open indefinitely.

Read More

Proposed Regulations Issued on Failure to Disclose Reportable Transaction Penalty Taking Into Account 2010 Law Change

The IRS has issued proposed regulations (REG-103033-11) that would provide guidance on the application of the failure to disclose a reportable transaction penalty found in IRC §6707A. 

Generally a taxpayer who participates in a reportable transaction must disclose such participation on any return affected by the transaction in question under IRC §6011.  A taxpayer who fails to make such a required disclosure (generally on a Form 8886) is subject to a penalty.

Read More

Plans that Fail to Offer Significant In-Patient Hospitalization and/or Physician Coverage Will Not Offer Minimum Value

In Notice 2014-69 the IRS has issued a warning regarding certain employer health plans it has learned about that have been designed to provide no, or extremely limited, in-patient hospitalization and/or physician coverage but still, due to quirks in the online minimum value calculator, be found to provide “minimum value” for health insurance.

The notice provides that plans that fail to provide significant in-patient hospitalization and/or physician coverage do provide minimum value and that regulations will shortly be issued to that effect. 

Read More

Gain on Repossession of Prior Residence Computed Under §1038 Not Eligible for §121 Exclusion, Taxpayer Taxed on All Cash Received

By repossessing a personal residence the taxpayer had sold by taking an installment note, the taxpayer ended up losing access to the IRC §121 $500,000 exclusion of gain on the sale of a principal residence in the case of Debough v. Commissioner, 141 TC No. 17, affd CA8, 2015 TNT 168-11, No. 14-3036.

The case deals with the interplay of IRC §121 (the exclusion for the gain on the sale of a qualifying residence) and IRC §1038 (a provision that is meant to offer relief when a taxpayer repossesses real property).  Effectively the Tax Court concluded that IRC §1038’s provisions trump the relief provision of IRC §121 in this fact pattern.

Read More

Partial Bad Debt Deduction Not to Be Allowed Where Taxpayer Established Reserve for Expected Collection

Taxpayers operating a trade or business are authorized to deduct partially worthless bad debts under Internal Revenue Code §166(a)(2). But to do so the taxpayers must be able to show that they are writing off a debt that already has gone bad, rather than simply reserving against a potentially bad debt in the future.

Read More

IRS Issues Proposed Regulations Upon Which Taxpayers May Rely Expanding Constructive Presence Days for Bona Fide Resident U.S. Territory Test

The IRS has issued proposed regulations (REG-109813-11) on which taxpayers may rely for new tax years that would allow additional days to count toward establishing bona fide residency for certain taxpayers in a U.S. territory.

Those qualifying as a bona fide resident of the following U.S. territories under IRC §937 are treated differently under a number of tax provisions:

  • Guam
  • American Samoa
  • The Northern Mariana Islands
  • Puerto Rico
  • The Virgin Islands [IRC §937(a)]
Read More

IRS Issues Temporary Regulations Addressing W2 Wages in §199 Cases and Proposed Regulations Addressing a Number of Other §199 Issues

The IRS has issued temporary regulations dealing with allocation of W-2 wages for purposes of the domestic production activities deduction (DPAD) of IRC §199, along with proposed regulations dealing with that topic along with other issues related to DPAD.   The temporary regulations are found in TD 9731 while the proposed regulations were released in REG-136459-09.

Read More

Cash Basis Taxpayer Who Has Not Elected Accrual Option for Foreign Tax Credit Reports Later Assessment for Credit Purposes in Year Paid

How taxpayers should deal with changes in the determination of foreign taxes due for purposes of the foreign tax credit was discussed in Chief Counsel Email 201534013.  Specifically, the question arose regarding a taxpayer on the cash basis of accounting who has not elected to report the foreign tax credit on the accrual basis that faced an additional assessment of foreign tax related to a prior year.

Read More