The question that had to be decided in the case of Barnhart Ranch Co. et al. v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2016-170 was whether the income and deductions from the cattle operations in question was actually the income of the Barnhardt brothers (as they had reported on their 1040s for the year in question) or rather the operations of the corporation. And, unfortunately for the taxpayers, this is once again a case where the taxpayers, being in charge of the form of a transaction, are not generally going to succeed arguing the substance of the transaction was different.
The brothers had reported net losses from the cattle operation for the years under exam of approximately $860,000 for 2010, $685,000 for 2011 and $970,000 for 2012, using those losses to offset other income reported on their returns. The IRS contended that those losses rather belonged on the return of BRC, Inc., a C corporation formed by the brothers in September 1994.
Image Copyright anatols / 123RF Stock Photo
Read More