Willful Failure to File FBAR Penalties Were Not Excessive
Another taxpayer had a bad experience with his failure to properly report all of his foreign accounts on his annual FBAR filing in the case of United States v. Collins.[1] The Court found no issue with the IRS’s assessment of penalties on the willful failure to file reports on these accounts for 2007 and 2008, despite the taxpayer’s attempt to argue that he had acted reasonably in failing to report these accounts and the amounts of the penalty were excessive.
Penalties the IRS Sought to Impose
The IRS was proposing civil penalties of $154,032 for 2007 and the same amount for 2008 for willful failure to report these accounts on the FBAR filings for the years in question. The IRS did not impose the maximum penalties (50% of the highest balance for each year) nor even an amount as high as their internal mitigation document suggested Mr. Collins would qualify for. As the opinion notes:
20. Under this internal mitigation guidance, the IRS would have assessed civil FBAR penalties against Mr. Collins of: (a) $382,666 for his willful failure to report his foreign accounts on an FBAR for 2007; and (b) $233,462 for his willful failure to report his foreign accounts on an FBAR for 2008. (Pl.'s Ex. P42; Trial Tr. at 49:15–50:12.)
Read More