IRS Position Not Substantially Justified With Regard to Taxpayer Basis Computation and Overall Method of Accounting
In the case of Morreale v. Commissioner[1] the Tax Court found that the IRS position in his case was not substantially justified, awarding the taxpayer attorney’s fees for the costs incurred on this matter—but this matter alone, and only at the statutory rate.
The taxpayer is a hotelier and restaurateur who operated in Denver. He failed to file income tax returns for 2011 and 2012 and in 2013 filed for bankruptcy. The IRS bankruptcy specialists referred the case to the Examination Division to assist in the preparation of substitutes for returns for 2011 and 2012.[2]
The taxpayer agreed to prepare the delinquent income tax returns. After the returns were submitted to the Revenue Agent, the RA proposed adjustments based on two primary issues:
The taxpayer had not substantiated basis in Sketch, LLC which operated two restaurants[3] and
The taxpayer had improperly reported income on the accrual basis of accounting, so that accrued but unpaid expenses were disallowed.[4]
