Substantiation, Entity Indebtedness, and Business Expense Deductibility: An Analysis of the Simmons Case
Cathryn A. Simmons v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-34 (April 22, 2026)
In a recent memorandum decision, the United States Tax Court addressed recurring substantiation issues surrounding closely held entities, commingled funds, and rental real estate deductions. The taxpayer, Cathryn A. Simmons, petitioned the Tax Court to challenge deficiency determinations issued by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) for the 2017 and 2019 tax years, alongside a 20% accuracy-related penalty assessed under Internal Revenue Code (I.R.C.) section 6662(a) for the 2017 tax year. Following several IRS concessions prior to and following trial, the remaining issues centered on whether Ms. Simmons adequately substantiated business deductions for a partnership she co-owned, deductible expenses associated with two rental properties, and whether she qualified for the reasonable cause exception to negate the accuracy-related penalty.
Read More