AICPA Again Loses on Question of Being Able to Challenge IRS Voluntary Unenrolled Preparer Registration After Case Returned to District Court
The AICPA ended up on the losing side of their case challenging the IRS's program to grant a credential to certain unenrolled preparers when the case returned to the US District Court for the DIstrict of Columbia on remand. (American Institute of Certified Public Accountants v. IRS et al.; No. 1:14-cv-01190, USDC DC, 8/3/16)
The IRS initially was successful in having the AICPA lawsuit dismissed. The ruling (American Institute of Certified Public Accountants v. IRS, et al., DC Dist Col, 114 AFTR 2d ¶2014-5386) held that the AICPA did not have standing to challenge the program. However the ruling was overturned on appeal to the DC Circuit (Docket No. 14-5309) with the appellate Court finding that the AICPA had shown the issuance of this registration could cause an actual or imminent increase in competition from CPAs due to the new government program, with the listing allowing them to compete more effectively against CPAs and potentially take business away. Thus, the panel found, the AICPA had competitor standing to challenge the program.
Read More