The IRS has been issuing a large number of frequently asked questions pages (referred to as FAQs) to deal with tax law in recent years, particularly with regard to issues under the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act and later legislation. The agency, in the case of Scholl, et al v. Mnuchin, et al, USDC ND CA, Case No. No. 4:20-cv-05309[1] had argued, among other things, that these FAQs are not “final agency actions” and thus not subject to review by the courts under the Administrative Procedures Act (APA) even in cases where the IRS is taking action directly related to the FAQ holdings.
The case involved the IRS FAQ, published on May 6, 2020, that in Q&A 15 took the position that incarcerated individuals were not eligible to receive an economic impact payment (EIP) under the CARES Act. The agency eventually took action to retrieve payments that had already been made to such individuals, asked any who had received them and not had them retrieved to send the money back and refused to issue any additional payments to such individuals.
Read More