Actor Failed to Properly Roll Over Non-Traditional Investment Held in IRA Account
The estate of actor James Caan contended that he had accurately rolled over the entire balance of an IRA from UBS to Merrill Lynch. The IRS largely concurred with this stance, save for the transfer of an interest in a non-publicly traded hedge fund. This asset encountered numerous challenges during its transfer from UBS to Merrill Lynch. Ultimately, the hedge fund interest was liquidated, and the proceeds were transferred to Merrill Lynch—nearly a year after UBS reported the fund’s distribution to Mr. Caan.
In Estate of Caan v. Commissioner,[1] the estate posited two potential explanations: either UBS never actually disbursed the hedge fund from the IRA, or the IRS unjustly declined to grant late rollover relief through a private letter ruling request. The Tax Court did not concur with either proposition. It determined that UBS had indeed disbursed the amount in 2015. Moreover, the IRS’s denial of relief was deemed appropriate since the exact asset distributed from the UBS IRA was not the one transferred to the new Merrill Lynch IRA, thus contravening the stipulations of IRC §408(d)(3)(A)(i).
Read More