Custom Manufacturing and the Section 41 Research Credit: A Technical Analysis of Intermountain Electronics, Inc. v. Commissioner
Intermountain Electronics, Inc. v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-118, Nov. 17, 2026
For tax professionals practicing in the federal research and development (R&D) credit arena under Internal Revenue Code (I.R.C.) § 41, the tension between custom design-manufacturing operations and statutory “qualified research” remains one of the most vigorously litigated frontiers. Taxpayers frequently assert that every customized engineering build constitutes qualified research, relying on high-level retrospective R&D studies. Conversely, the Internal Revenue Service routinely scrutinizes whether shop-floor adaptations, routine engineering calculations, and customer-funded deliverables meet the exacting four-part statutory test of I.R.C. § 41(d).
In Intermountain Electronics, Inc. v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-118 (filed November 17, 2026), the United States Tax Court, with Judge Buch presiding, delivered a comprehensive, highly technical analysis examining research credit claims arising from thousands of custom manufacturing projects. The decision underscores a decisive judicial boundary: while proprietary, “clean-sheet” product development conducted by dedicated research personnel readily satisfies I.R.C. § 41, customer-driven build-to-order manufacturing projects routinely fail. Specifically, the court held that custom manufacturing projects fail where the taxpayer relies on post-hoc time allocations, fails to segregate routine production from investigatory experimentation, concedes intellectual property rights in customer contracts, or confuses general engineering complexity with objective statutory uncertainty under I.R.C. § 174.
Factual Background and Manufacturing Operations
Intermountain Electronics, Inc. (Intermountain) is a Utah-based corporation with its principal place of business in Price, Utah. The company was founded in January 1985 by John Houston following a catastrophic mine fire at Emery Mining Co. in December 1984 that claimed the lives of 27 miners. Initially established to repair and recondition electrical equipment used in underground coal mining, Intermountain expanded substantially over three decades. With the addition of co-owner Tom Akers in the late 1990s, the company established manufacturing facilities in Centralia, Illinois, and South Point, Ohio, near major coal basins, and subsequently opened a facility in Denver, Colorado, to serve the oil and gas sector.
Intermountain operates principally as a manufacturer of highly specialized, custom electrical distribution and power control equipment designed to withstand extreme underground and surface environments. Its commercial product line includes custom switchgears, load centers (power transformers), variable frequency drive (VFD) packages, lease automatic custody transfer (LACT) units, saltwater disposal (SWD) skids, and walk-in electrical houses (e-houses). In underground mining applications, these assemblies must endure caustic elements (e.g., trona, potash, and coal dust), severe dimensional constraints imposed by shafts and tunnels, explosive atmospheric gases (methane), and thermal dissipation bottlenecks.
In addition to custom contract manufacturing, Intermountain maintains an internal research and development department led by Dale Curtis. This internal department engaged in the proprietary development of advanced, patent-protected electronic components, notably ground lock technology monitors (the GLT 500 and the microprocessor-driven GMS 504-DZ) designed to prevent electrocution while minimizing costly false “nuisance trips” in mining operations.
Intermountain executed its custom commercial projects under fixed-fee contracts. Projects typically commenced with a customer request or tender, followed by preliminary engineering reviews, price quotations, purchase orders, and sales order acknowledgments. To manage shop-floor operations, Intermountain utilized an Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) platform (Epicor). However, while Epicor systematically captured materials, supplies, purchase orders, and direct shop-floor hourly manufacturing labor (fabrication, welding, painting, assembly), salaried engineers and project managers did not log contemporaneous time in the system prior to or during design phases.
The Taxpayer’s Credit Claims and Request for Relief
Intermountain engaged a national tax consulting firm, alliantgroup, LP, to conduct a retrospective research credit study covering taxable years 2010 through 2015. Lacking contemporaneous project-by-project time records for its engineering and supervisory staff, the consulting firm performed statistical sampling and conducted retrospective interviews with project managers and lead personnel to estimate the percentage of qualified research time. The firm then quantified qualified research expenditures (QREs) by applying these estimated percentages to employees’ gross W-2 wages.
Relying on the alliantgroup studies, Intermountain filed amended federal corporate income tax returns for the taxable years 2012, 2013, 2014, and 2015, claiming substantial research credits and credit carryforwards under I.R.C. § 41:
- Tax Year 2012: $1,458,436
- Tax Year 2013: $1,526,866
- Tax Year 2014: $1,559,625
- Tax Year 2015: $1,118,811
For credit computation purposes, Intermountain elected the Alternative Simplified Credit (ASC) method under I.R.C. § 41(c)(5) for 2012 and 2013, and the regular credit method under I.R.C. § 41(c)(1)–(3) for 2014 and 2015.
Upon examination, the Commissioner of Internal Revenue completely disallowed all claimed research credits and carryforwards. On April 19, 2019, the Commissioner issued a statutory Notice of Deficiency determining substantial income tax deficiencies:
- Tax Year 2012: $880,433
- Tax Year 2013: $1,051,499
- Tax Year 2014: $498,847
- Tax Year 2015: $873,332
Intermountain timely filed a petition with the United States Tax Court under I.R.C. § 6213(a) requesting a redetermination of the deficiencies, asserting full entitlement to the claimed research credits and associated QREs across thousands of underlying projects. To facilitate trial administration, the Tax Court instructed the parties to select a representative sample of twelve projects (six chosen by the taxpayer, six by the Commissioner) to adjudicate credit eligibility.
Burden of Proof and Evidentiary Thresholds
The court opened its legal analysis by emphasizing foundational tax litigation principles. Under Tax Court Rule 142(a) and the seminal doctrine of Welch v. Helvering, 290 U.S. 111, 115 (1933), the Commissioner’s determinations in a notice of deficiency carry a presumption of correctness, placing the burden of proof squarely on the taxpayer. Deductions and tax credits are matters of legislative grace; accordingly, the taxpayer must demonstrate precise compliance with every statutory and regulatory condition precedent (Feigh v. Commissioner, 152 T.C. 267, 270 (2019); INDOPCO, Inc. v. Commissioner, 503 U.S. 79, 84 (1992)).
Under I.R.C. § 41(a)(1), the research credit equals 20 percent of the excess of the taxpayer’s QREs for the taxable year over the base amount. QREs comprise in-house research expenses and contract research expenses (I.R.C. § 41(b)(1)). In-house research expenses encompass:
- Wages paid or incurred to an employee for qualified services (I.R.C. § 41(b)(2)(A)(i)); and
- Amounts paid or incurred for supplies used in the conduct of qualified research (I.R.C. § 41(b)(2)(A)(ii)).
Qualified services consist of engaging in qualified research, or engaging in the direct supervision or direct support of qualified research (I.R.C. § 41(b)(2)(B); Treas. Reg. § 1.41-2(c)(3)). Under the “substantially all” wage allocation rule of Treas. Reg. § 1.41-2(d)(2), if at least 80 percent of the services performed by an employee during a taxable year constitute qualified services, 100 percent of the wages paid to that employee may be treated as QREs.
The Four-Part Statutory Test for Qualified Research
To qualify under I.R.C. § 41(d)(1), activities must satisfy a rigorous four-part test applied separately at the business component level (I.R.C. § 41(d)(2)(A)):
The Section 174 Test
Under I.R.C. § 41(d)(1)(A), the expenditures must be eligible for expensing under I.R.C. § 174. Section 174 provides an elective exception to the capital expenditure rules of I.R.C. §§ 263(a) and 263A for “research and development costs in the experimental or laboratory sense” (Treas. Reg. § 1.174-2(a)(1)). These represent costs incident to the development or improvement of a product. As articulated by the court:
“Research and development costs in the experimental or laboratory sense are for ‘activities intended to discover information that would eliminate uncertainty concerning the development or improvement of a product. Uncertainty exists if the information available to the taxpayer does not establish the capability or method for developing or improving the product or the appropriate design of the product.’”
Citing Union Carbide Corp. & Subs. v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2009-50, aff’d, 697 F.3d 104 (2d Cir. 2012), Judge Buch applied a strict two-step inquiry:
- The taxpayer must demonstrate that information objectively available to it does not establish the capability, method, or appropriate design of the product (objective uncertainty); and
- The taxpayer must demonstrate that it actually undertook investigative activities intended to discover information to eliminate that uncertainty.
Crucially, the court reinforced the objective standard of uncertainty:
“‘Whether an uncertainty exists is an objective test that depends on the information available to the taxpayer.’ Expenditures that are paid after the elimination of uncertainty are not research and development expenditures... Furthermore, it bears emphasis that uncertainty related to a subcomponent does not necessarily render the appropriate design of the product as a whole uncertain.”
Relying on Betz v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2023-84, and Max v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2021-37, the court highlighted that standard engineering modeling and calculations do not constitute investigatory activities:
“However, performing basic calculations on available data is not an investigative activity because the taxpayer already has all the information necessary to address what was unknown... A taxpayer cannot carry its burden to show that it engaged in investigative activities merely by presenting an issue and eventual solution. Instead, the taxpayer must show it actually conducted investigatory activities.”
The Technological Information Test
Under I.R.C. § 41(d)(1)(B)(i) and Treas. Reg. § 1.41-4(a)(4), the research must be undertaken for the purpose of discovering information that is technological in nature—meaning it fundamentally relies on principles of the physical sciences, biological sciences, engineering, or computer science. The court noted that Intermountain’s activities drew generally from electrical and mechanical engineering principles.
The Business Component Test
Under I.R.C. § 41(d)(1)(B)(ii) and § 41(d)(2)(B), the taxpayer must intend that the information discovered be useful in the development of a new or improved business component (a product, process, software, technique, formula, or invention held for sale, lease, license, or used in the taxpayer’s trade or business). To satisfy this test, the research must provide some functional level of improvement (Union Carbide, 97 T.C.M. (CCH) at 1255).
The Process of Experimentation Test
Under I.R.C. § 41(d)(1)(C) and Treas. Reg. § 1.41-4(a)(5)(i), substantially all of the research activities must constitute elements of a process of experimentation for a qualified purpose—namely, a new or improved function, performance, reliability, or quality (I.R.C. § 41(d)(3)).
A process of experimentation is a process designed to evaluate one or more alternatives to achieve a result where the capability, method, or appropriate design is uncertain at the outset, and which follows the principles of the scientific method (Union Carbide, 97 T.C.M. (CCH) at 1256).
Under the “substantially all” requirement of Treas. Reg. § 1.41-4(a)(6), at least 80 percent of the research activities for each business component—measured on a cost or other consistently applied reasonable basis—must constitute elements of a process of experimentation. As established in Little Sandy Coal Co. v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2021-15, aff’d, 62 F.4th 287 (7th Cir. 2023), the numerator comprises activities that constitute a process of experimentation, while the denominator comprises all activities that satisfy I.R.C. § 174 and are not otherwise excluded under I.R.C. § 41(d)(4).
Judge Buch firmly rejected the taxpayer’s attempt to satisfy this test by referencing its high-level, seven-phase standard design procedure:
“‘Merely connecting an activity to a larger plan that may resemble the scientific method does not satisfy the process of experimentation test.’ While the design process as framed by Intermountain may appear similar to the scientific method, Intermountain’s blanket argument is not sufficient for us to find that Intermountain employees engaged in a process of experimentation.”
Pilot Models and Supply Expense Thresholds
A central issue for custom equipment manufacturers is whether the raw materials and components incorporated into customer deliverables qualify as QRE supplies under I.R.C. § 41(b)(2)(A)(ii).
The court reiterated the longstanding principle that I.R.C. § 174 limits deductions to:
“‘expenditures of an investigative nature expended in developing the concept of a model or product’, as opposed to the construction or manufacture of the product itself... Consequently, a deduction under section 174 is generally not available with respect to costs of production, and claimed QREs incurred in the actual production of a product typically fail the section 174 test.”
While Treas. Reg. § 1.174-2(a)(4) provides an exception for “pilot models” (defined as any representation or model of a product produced to evaluate and resolve uncertainty concerning the product, including fully functional models), the classification turns strictly on the taxpayer’s intent. Citing Little Sandy Coal Co., 62 F.4th at 303, and Betz, T.C. Memo. 2023-84, the court observed:
“The record does not support the contention that Intermountain’s projects were pilot models. Like those of the taxpayers in Betz, Intermountain’s projects did not create models, but rather the ‘final product itself.’”
Because Intermountain produced customer equipment for ultimate commercial delivery rather than experimental evaluation models, its supply expenditures failed the I.R.C. § 174 threshold.
Substantiation Requirements and Limitations on the Cohan Doctrine
Taxpayers claiming research credits must maintain books and records in a “sufficiently usable form and detail to substantiate that the expenditures claimed are eligible for the credit” (I.R.C. § 6001; Treas. Reg. § 1.6001-1(a); Treas. Reg. § 1.41-4(d)).
While contemporaneous time tracking is not an absolute statutory prerequisite (Union Carbide, 97 T.C.M. (CCH) at 1268; Fudim v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 1994-235), the court stressed critical legal boundaries governing the Cohan estimation doctrine (Cohan v. Commissioner, 39 F.2d 540 (2d Cir. 1930)). Citing Shami v. Commissioner, 741 F.3d 560, 568 (5th Cir. 2014), the court affirmed:
“‘[T]he Cohan rule is not implicated unless the taxpayer proves that he is entitled to some amount of tax benefit[;] [i]n the context of the § 41 credit, a taxpayer would do so by proving that its employee performed some qualified services.’”
Moreover, under Eustace v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2001-66, aff’d, 312 F.3d 905 (7th Cir. 2002), if a business component fails as a whole, the taxpayer cannot invoke Cohan at the subcomponent level unless it presents credible substantiation tying specific employees and wages directly to qualifying subcomponent activities.
Statutory Exclusions: Funded Research, Adaptation, and Routine Testing
Under I.R.C. § 41(d)(4), qualified research explicitly excludes:
- Adaptation or duplication of an existing business component (subparagraphs (B) and (C));
- Routine or ordinary testing or inspection for quality control (subparagraph (D)(v); Treas. Reg. § 1.174-2(a)(6)–(7); Eustace, 312 F.3d at 907); and
- Funded research (subparagraph (H)).
The funded research doctrine proved dispositive for major contract work. Under Treas. Reg. § 1.41-4A(d), research is treated as funded if either:
- Amounts payable are not contingent on the success of the research (the financial risk test; Fairchild Indus., Inc. v. United States, 71 F.3d 868, 870 (Fed. Cir. 1995)); or
- The taxpayer retains no substantial rights in the research results (Lockheed Martin Corp. v. United States, 210 F.3d 1366, 1376 (Fed. Cir. 2000); Tangel v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2021-1; Dynetics, Inc. & Subs. v. United States, 121 Fed. Cl. 492, 523 (2015)).
Under Treas. Reg. § 1.41-4A(d)(2), a taxpayer retains no substantial rights if the agreement confers exclusive exploitation rights on another person, or if the taxpayer must pay to use the research results. Crucially, incidental benefits—such as increased experience or general know-how—do not constitute substantial rights.
Application of Legal Standards to Representative Sample Projects
The court evaluated the twelve trial projects across the two primary categories: customer-contracted custom manufacturing projects (ten projects) and internal proprietary product developments (two projects).
Customer Contract Custom Manufacturing Projects
The ten customer-driven commercial projects failed to qualify for the research credit due to fatal substantiation, legal, or statutory defects:
Project 20047X: Hillsboro Longwall Project
Intermountain contracted with Hillsboro Energy to design and manufacture an entire underground longwall mining power distribution train, featuring automated self-propelling CAT tracks, a ceiling-mounted motorized monorail festoon system, and a custom 9 MVA power center split into three 3 MVA transformers to accommodate tight entryways.
Court Holding: Although the project satisfied the business component test and Intermountain faced genuine I.R.C. § 174 design uncertainty regarding the novel CAT track and monorail integration, the taxpayer failed to substantiate qualifying wage expenses. Intermountain produced conflicting trial exhibits regarding engineering hours (one exhibit reflected 374 hours across subprojects, while another showed 222.15 engineering hours alongside thousands of shop-floor fabrication hours). Because engineering hours were estimated retrospectively and engineers did not track time in Epicor, the court found the allocation unreliable. Furthermore, the project failed the 80 percent “substantially all” requirement of Treas. Reg. § 1.41-4(a)(6).
Project 205662: Kearl Oil Sands Expansion Project
Intermountain contracted with general contractor ThyssenKrupp Robins, Inc. to fabricate seven modular e-houses for an oil sands mining operation owned by Imperial Oil in Alberta, Canada.
Court Holding: The project was wholly disqualified as funded research under I.R.C. § 41(d)(4)(H). Section 20 of the purchase agreement expressly provided that ThyssenKrupp retained exclusive ownership of intellectual property, restricted Intermountain from using project information for any other project or disclosing it to third parties, granted ThyssenKrupp a perpetual, worldwide, royalty-free exclusive licensing right, and required Intermountain and its personnel to assign all inventions conceived during the contract or within one year thereafter.
The court rejected Intermountain’s contention that surrendering patent rights did not forfeit substantial rights:
“In considering contract terms in a similar case, the Court of Federal Claims asked ‘how [the taxpayer] could have substantial rights in the results of the research, if it needed the [purchaser’s] ‘authorization’ to use those results.’ Dynetics, Inc. & Subs., 121 Fed. Cl. at 521... It is challenging to imagine what, if any, rights Intermountain retains in the work product at all. These terms transfer all substantial rights to ThyssenKrupp.”
In the alternative, the court held the project failed the I.R.C. § 174 test (designing e-houses was routine work; flipping layouts in 3D CADD to create mirror-image units was standard engineering, not investigative experimentation) and failed the 80 percent substantially all requirement.
Project 209564-1-1: Tallgrass Holyoke E-House
The first of five pipeline pressure-boosting e-houses constructed for Tallgrass Energy, requiring a custom structural “moment frame” to withstand severe wind loads and thermal modeling for rooftop HVAC units.
Court Holding: While the business component test was met and I.R.C. § 174 uncertainty existed regarding structural and thermal constraints for Intermountain’s longest building, the claim failed for lack of wage substantiation. Records contained conflicting hours; hours were estimated retrospectively; and the lead engineer admitted testifying to applying engineering hours to other duplicate units. The project also failed the 80 percent process of experimentation test.
Project 209873-1-1: Hess GN-Cambrian E-House
An automated lease automatic custody transfer (LACT) unit manufactured for Hess Corp. in North Dakota.
Court Holding: Failed the I.R.C. § 174 test. Internal engineering checklists designated the project as a “repeat job” based on a prior Intermountain job, noted “NA” for pre-production reviews, confirmed that complete electrical schematics were provided directly by the customer, and showed only 0.02 engineering hours compared to 527 production hours. Intermountain possessed all requisite information from inception.
Project 210464-1-1: Whiting Saltwater Disposal Skid
A prefabricated automated pumping skid built for Whiting Petroleum Corp. to separate briny water from extracted crude oil.
Court Holding: Failed the I.R.C. § 174 test. Intermountain faced no objective uncertainty regarding capability or design; internal records revealed that the selected pump had been used in prior SWD locations. Citing Betz, T.C. Memo. 2023-84, at *76, the court stressed that uncertainty regarding a single subcomponent does not render the entire skid uncertain. The taxpayer also failed to substantiate hours or satisfy the 80 percent experimentation test.
Project 210554-1-1: Whiting E-House
A modular steel electrical house fabricated for the North Antelope Rochelle Mine.
Court Holding: Failed both the business component test and the I.R.C. § 174 test. The project utilized a standard building stock design. Intermountain logged only 3.83 engineering hours versus over 100 manufacturing hours. The court observed:
“The consequence of repetition is expertise. This project represents minor alterations to a standard, stock design and did not involve resolving any section 174 uncertainty.”
Project 208277-2-1: Whiting Dual 500 HP Stage Loader VFD Controller
A belt-speed controller subcomponent manufactured for a longwall conveyor system.
Court Holding: Failed the business component and I.R.C. § 174 tests. Intermountain established only 3.52 engineering hours and failed to demonstrate that the build provided functional improvements. The court rebuffed the argument that technical sophistication equates to research:
“Rather, we are left to infer that, because the product was complicated, research was required. This does not suffice.”
Project 024649-1-1: Morgantown Electrical Controller
Rebuilding and repair of an electrical controller for a longwall mobile tailpiece.
Court Holding: Failed the I.R.C. § 174 and experimentation tests. Intermountain logged 25.1 employee hours exclusively as “repair hours.” The court ruled that equipment repair does not constitute research in the experimental sense.
Project 206901-1-1: North Antelope Flash Protection Door
A heavy-duty blast door designed to redirect arc-flash concussions away from mine personnel.
Court Holding: Failed the I.R.C. § 174 and experimentation tests. Intermountain had built arc-flash assemblies previously. Records showed only 19.24 laser-cutting hours and 4.58 painting hours, with zero engineering or testing hours.
Project 69545: Minero Bolero Mine Transformer
A replacement power center transformer built for a Mexican mining client.
Court Holding: Failed the I.R.C. § 174 and experimentation tests. Intermountain offered only generalized assertions regarding transformer physics. Records showed 190.95 hours for fabrication, assembly, and painting, with zero engineering or testing hours.
Proprietary Internal Research and Development Projects
In stark contrast to the customer manufacturing contracts, Intermountain’s two internal proprietary development projects met every statutory test:
Project RD-0000: The GLT 500 Ground Monitor
Commenced in 2011, this project was a clean-sheet initiative to develop a groundbreaking ground lock technology monitor. The device incorporated a bi-color status LED, current monitoring sensors, latching fault indicators, and a patented external communication port allowing remote telemetry. To overcome fatal field failures caused by coal dust ingress and high-voltage electrical arcing, Intermountain radically redesigned internal switchgear housings and circuit boards using extensive laboratory prototyping.
Project RD-0009: The GMS 504-DZ Microprocessor Ground Monitor
Commenced in 2012, this project developed a software-driven, digital multi-signal monitor that functioned as four synchronized ground monitors in a single enclosure. It utilized proprietary algorithmic test signals to differentiate between legitimate dangerous ground faults and harmless transient noise, eliminating costly nuisance trips. Intermountain developed custom alpha firmware, performed environmental chamber testing, and secured patents.
Court Holding: Both proprietary projects satisfied the four-part test under I.R.C. § 41(d). The R&D department head, Dale Curtis, and dedicated engineering interns (Erramouspe and Wayman) devoted verifiable time to hypothesis testing, circuit modeling, and iterative experimentation. The court accepted the testimony and records substantiating in-house employee wage QREs and prototype supply QREs for all years in issue (2012 through 2015), concluding that the alliantgroup records and trial testimony established reliable cost baselines. However, third-party contractor expenses claimed for these projects were disallowed because Intermountain failed to provide adequate substantiating documentation.
Judicial Conclusions and Practice Implications
The Tax Court concluded its opinion by framing the core dilemma of modern custom manufacturing tax credit claims, quoting its prior decision in Phoenix Design Group:
“As we said in Phoenix Design Group, T.C. Memo. 2024-113, at *45, ‘engineers solve problems you did not know you had in ways you cannot understand.’ We believe that this is very much the case with projects completed by Intermountain. With the exception of the proprietary research projects, Intermountain failed to substantiate its entitlement to research credits under section 41. For those proprietary projects, Intermountain established that it is entitled to the research credit to the extent of the amounts paid to its own employees involved in the proprietary research projects.”
For CPAs, EAs, and tax controversy practitioners, Intermountain Electronics establishes several vital operational takeaways:
First, custom manufacturing is not per se qualified research. The presence of complex customer specifications, harsh operating environments, or tight engineering tolerances does not establish objective statutory uncertainty under I.R.C. § 174. Where an enterprise possesses the foundational engineering expertise to design and construct a product, subsequent design modifications and layout revisions represent routine technical proficiency rather than investigative experimentation.
Second, retrospective wage studies remain exceptionally vulnerable. Reliance on post-hoc interviews, unverified percentage allocations, and gross salary estimates without contemporaneous project accounting will fail when scrutinized under Rule 142(a). If an ERP system logs production shop hours but captures negligible or estimated engineering time, courts will reject the allocations as uncorroborated. Furthermore, the Cohan rule cannot rescue a credit claim where the taxpayer fails to prove that specific employees performed qualified services on an identifiable qualifying component.
Third, production costs and customer deliverables are not pilot models. Claiming raw materials, laser-cut steel, and production components as supply QREs under the pilot model exception fails where the product is constructed for commercial delivery to a customer. Only representations built specifically to evaluate and resolve design uncertainties qualify under Treas. Reg. § 1.174-2(a)(4).
Fourth, contract terms govern funded research exclusions. Tax practitioners must audit customer master service agreements and purchase orders. Even where a taxpayer bears 100 percent of the financial risk under a fixed-fee agreement, granting an exclusive license, agreeing not to use the design on other customer projects, or executing broad IP assignment clauses forfeits “substantial rights” under Treas. Reg. § 1.41-4A(d), completely disqualifying the project from credit eligibility.
Finally, the shrink-back rule requires granular accounting. A taxpayer cannot invoke the shrink-back rule of Treas. Reg. § 1.41-4(b)(2) without project accounting that isolates specific qualified labor and supply expenditures directly to the qualifying subcomponent.
Prepared with assistance from Gemini Notebook.
