In the case of Luque v. Commissioner, TC Memo 2016-128 the taxpayers had overpaid their 2011 tax. However, between the time the taxpayers filed a 2011 return in April of 2012 and when the IRS determined that the tax for 2011 was higher than that reported, the original overpayment amount had been applied by the IRS to an outstanding liability the taxpayers had for 2009.
At trial the IRS conceded that there was, in fact, no underreporting of tax for 2011 and so that the Tax Court should rule at this point that there is no tax due nor any overpayment on the 2011 return. The taxpayers, while agreeing they did not owe anything to the IRS wanted the Court to order the IRS to pay them the amount of the 2011 overpayment.
Read More